Free Competition Fundamentals for Intellectual Property Attorneys

Competition law or Antitrust has become an increasingly important tool in markets with a high component of intellectual property rights and other intangibles. Major cases in recent years, whether in the context of conduct investigations or mergers, have centered around issues like access refusals to technologies or pharmaceutical patents and billion-dollar acquisitions of businesses focused on high-performance software generation. Additionally, tools built on intellectual property are gaining central importance for competition agencies, which require powerful technological systems for data collection and analysis, especially to supervise digital economy businesses.
This scenario of increasingly constant interaction requires Intellectual Property professionals to develop a thorough understanding of the implications that Free Competition may have on their professional practice. This could be to mitigate risks so that legal advice does not lead to anticompetitive implications or to enable the professional to develop creative strategies that integrate antitrust concepts alongside typical intellectual property arguments.

General Information

Area(s)

    Competition Law
    Franchises
    Patent Law
    Technologies
    Valuation of Intangibles

Coordinators

  • Luis Diez Canseco Núñez
  • Omar Alvarado Escobar

Evaluation System

In the last module, a group evaluation will be conducted. Groups will be predetermined two weeks in advance.

Each group will be assigned a recent real case. The group is expected to make a 15-minute presentation in class, in which they will: (i) narrate the facts and identify the main legal issues under discussion, (ii) give their opinion on the case, and (iii) answer 2 or 3 questions from other students and/or the evaluating professors.

Teaching hours

16

Class duration

2 hrs.

Number of modules

8

Period

September 11th to October 30th (on Wednesdays)

Quotas

CLOSED

Schedule

4 p.m. to 6 p.m. (Lima, Bogotá, Quito Time)

Platform

Zoom

Zoom

Language

Spanish

English (translation)


Objectives

The main objective is for professionals specializing in intellectual property to develop a sense of "alertness" or awareness of the implications that free competition can have on their activities. The goal is not to achieve expert knowledge but to gain basic training in essential legal institutions of free competition, enabling them to integrate this knowledge into their daily work. Simply put, the aim is for intellectual property professionals to formulate questions that transcend intellectual property when advising their clients. Questions like, "Could the way I litigate to protect my patent be considered anticompetitive and lead to market foreclosure?" or "Could territorial allocations under my franchise scheme and some franchisee selection rules entail antitrust liability?" are examples of the type of "sensitivity" we want the professionals trained in this course to develop.

Investment

Content

(Español) Conceptos económicos y legales básicos sobre propiedad intelectual, competencia desleal y libre competencia

Objective:

This is an introductory session where foundational concepts will be addressed, and a broad explanation of the bases of convergence among the three disciplines will be provided. However, given the course objectives, emphasis will be placed on the study of legal situations involving intangible assets and their implications from the perspective of free competition.

- Market failures: public goods, free riding, monopoly (legal monopolies, natural monopolies), equilibrium price.
- How do these economic concepts interrelate? Market failures that each discipline seeks to minimize and the interaction between them to achieve those purposes.
- Systematic location of the three disciplines as part of market regulatory law.
- Historical evolution, policy and origins.

Wednesday, September 11, 2024

Typical conducts in free competition: abuse of dominant position (Session 1)

Objective:

The concept of abuse of dominant position will be introduced, and the range of the most common behaviors under this modality will be presented.

- What is the abuse of dominant position?
- How is this figure addressed in the most relevant regulations (US and EU)?
- Introduction to the role of intellectual property in this type of case.
- Most common cases: unjustified refusal of treatment, discrimination. Case studies of actions against Fintech businesses, which are expanding in Latin America, will be proposed.

Wednesday, September 18, 2024

Keynote lecture: Free competition, new technologies and intellectual property

Objective: It will explain the perspective of the main competition authorities in the world (US and EU) regarding digital markets and intellectual property-intensive industries.
Content:
- The policy agenda and oversight priorities on both sides of the Atlantic.
- Recent cases of investigations against big techs.
- Recent cases on the use of collusive algorithms and hub and spoke.

Monday, September 23, 2024

Typical Conduct in competition law: horizontal collusions

Objective:

This session will conceptually introduce horizontal collusion, referring to agreements between competitors, with an emphasis on arrangements involving intellectual property. Typical cases will be explained, and relevant jurisprudence will be provided.

- What is horizontal collusion?
- Essential difference: Naked cartels and agreements not subject to absolute prohibition (ancillary doctrine).
- How is this concept included in the most relevant regulations (US and EU)?
- Cases involving intellectual property: setting of standards and technical norms.
- Assumptions related to intellectual property: Collaboration agreements (R&D).

Wednesday, October 2, 2024

Typical Conducts in competition law: vertical collusions

Objective:

This session will conceptually introduce vertical collusion, referring to agreements between agents at different levels of the commercial chain (e.g., manufacturers and distributors, distributors and retailers). The presentation will emphasize arrangements involving intellectual property, explaining typical cases and providing relevant jurisprudence.

- What is vertical collusion?
- How is this figure included in the most relevant regulations (US and EU)?
- Most common cases: exclusivities, resale price maintenance (RPM).
- Cases related to intellectual property: franchises.
- Cases related to intellectual property: exclusive selection.

Wednesday, October 9, 2024

Intellectual Property in the context of merger operations

Objective:

The main "deals" these days have a high intellectual property component. Targets are chosen not for their advantages from the typical brick-and-mortar perspective, but for their intangible assets (e.g., software, data). This session aims to train intellectual property professionals to understand how these intangibles influence M&A operations.

- What is a merger operation? Conceptual elements that must be met for a notifiable operation (change of control and thresholds).
- The role of intellectual property as a relevant asset that allows for control.
- The valuation of IP as a factor in determining thresholds.
- M&A of intangible assets as a competition risk and the closure of certain markets.
- Examples of relevant global operations: mergers in the pharmaceutical industry, between content producers/platforms, between software companies, and killer acquisitions.

Wednesday, October 16, 2024

Typical conducts in antitrust law: abuse of dominance (Session 2)

Objective:

We will continue with the development of case law on abuse of dominance (topic addressed in Module 2), focusing on the provision of case law.

  1. The Sham Litigation case: its origin in patent casuistry. Recent case law.
  2.  Standard Essential Patents and Fair, Reasonable and Non-Discriminatory - FRANDs.
  3. Generic registrations as trademarks, as an act of monopolistic obstruction and/or acts of unfair competition.

Wednesday, October 23, 2024

Group Case Presentation

Objective:

Based on the study of real cases, the groups will apply the knowledge learned and share their main findings and comments with the rest of the class.

Wednesday, October 30, 2024

Don't miss the opportunity to learn
about current intellectual property issues.
Join today!

Otros Programas ASIPI